My recent musings about weed seem to have sparked a bit of thought amongst readers.  I had an email from Gavin P yesterday which helps to identify the species we are dealing with and recounts his own experience in trying to keep the stuff under control.

Ian
 
just bit of info regarding this weed
 
Regarding the weed problems in the tarn I have found that it is mainly either hornwort or myriphillum species and not Canadian pond weed.  as a keeper of Koi carp for around 30 plus years I used to use this as spawning material in the early days when spawning brushes where not around and even now this weed still occasionally crops up in my pond which is generally quiet sterile and around 10000 gallons, and I have not been able to eradicate this weed even after completely emptying the pond numerous times it keeps making a appearance and this year is no exception.
 
the one main benefit is that it will keep the water clean and pure and generally as I have found prevents blanket weed and the invasive strains of algae.
 
As I am sure you are aware we as anglers are guilty of promoting this weed by over stocking which raises the level of nutrients in the water. now to the crux of the tale is the introduction of the grass carp into our lakes which was thought to be a general cure all to remove soft weed and it did appear effective in the initial stages but did increase the nutrient levels even further which resulted in firstly the reduction of weed levels by the fish which was great for the angler but the down side of this was that there was nothing to prevent the algae/ blanket weed blooms due to the high nutrient levels which where still there. a further result was that the algae appeared to reduce absorption of O2. this was in the forums of many of the leading fish breeders in the early years. therefore a difficult choice in how to deal with this weed. further to the introduction of this alien carp into our fisheries it was found if I am not mistaken that clarity of the water became a problem through weed disturbance from younger growth which was on the lake bed and was softer to the carp which uprooted these weeds from the lake bed and put silt into the higher levels of water.these weeds whilst not directly rooted they do send enough roots down to anchor them. the end result was cloudy water.
 
I hope this information is of interest and helps in your thought on the weed front but the main contribution to the excessive weed is the high stock levels just to keep the angler happy.
 
Also how this related to modern thinking on natural weed control I have no idea but must be still relevant
 
regards

Gavin

I am becoming ever more convinced that a bit of judicious raking to create clear "bays" is the most practical and environmentally acceptable answer.  If the weather holds then I may well do a small trial area on Sunday and see how easy this proves to be and what the effect is.  My thought is to clear  a patch up near the hut where the water is wade able and the result is unlikely to have any lasting effect on the rest of the Tarn.  We shall see.

We have a day pretty much like yesterday with a fair bit of high cloud, little wind and a reasonable temperature.  If this lasts till tomorrow then we should have ideal conditions for the riverfly exercise.

Ian